Has Victoria's Secret Changed, or Did We Just Change the Name of the Costume?
In 2019, Victoria's Secret cancelled its show. Not out of grace, out of exhaustion: its own marketing chief had said out loud that trans women and plus-size models didn't belong because "the show is a fantasy," ratings had been sliding for years, and the whole brand reeked of a kind of sexism nobody wanted to buy in sequins anymore. We all agreed, didn't we? The show died because it deserved to. Even when the backlash hit their "The Perfect Body" campaign — five identical bodies under that label — they quietly swapped it for "A Body for Every Body" within a week, under pressure from 27,000 signatures. We won that one. Or so we thought.
It came back in 2024 wearing a different costume. "Reflects who we are today," they said. They brought in Ashley Graham, women in their 50s, language about inclusion and diversity everywhere. And a part of me, the 90s kid who grew up treating that show like a December ritual, wanted to believe they'd actually understood something.
And to be fair, I have to give them this: there is real plus-size casting this time. Ashley Graham, Paloma Elsesser, a trans model in Alex Consani. That's not just marketing. That's a real shift from what the show was selling in 2018.
But here's where it gets complicated, and where this story stopped being abstract for me. Bringing in new bodies hasn't come with any gesture toward the women who were already there. Romee Strijd, Angel for years, cut from the 2026 casting. Frida Aasen, cut too. Lais Ribeiro, the one who wore the Fantasy Bra in 2017, reportedly cut as well. Meanwhile influencers with zero runway history are walking in, and fans have noticed: "are they really putting influencers in instead of actual Angels?"
I have to be honest about why Romee is the one who gets to me. I watched her walk for years. I was one of those girls glued to the TV every December, and she was one of the faces I associated with that whole dream. Then in 2020 she told the truth about it: seven years without a period, a body that stopped functioning because of what the show demanded she maintain. She didn't sell the fantasy clean. She told us what it cost. She was one of the few Angels who said, out loud, that underneath the wings there was a body that broke down. As a woman who watched her walk for years and then watched her tell that story, it genuinely hurts to watch her crying in a TikTok this week because she wasn't chosen this time.
So my question isn't really "is Victoria's Secret still exclusionary about body size." That answer is more complicated than I wanted it to be, and I'd rather be accurate than righteous. My real question is this: does this brand, now that it's fluent in the language of inclusion, actually want the women who put a price on what it cost to build it anywhere near the runway? Or does it just want new, diverse bodies in frame, and the ones who spoke honestly somewhere else, quietly, off camera?
I can't prove a direct line between what Romee said and why she got cut. Victoria's Secret hasn't explained its reasoning, not to her, not to Aasen. Rumors aren't evidence. But the question sits there anyway, and I think it's worth asking: a brand can become genuinely more diverse in bodies and still be exactly as uncomfortable with the truth as it always was.
So no, I don't think Victoria's Secret changed. I think it learned the vocabulary we demanded in 2019 and put it on like makeup. The show is still a casting. It still decides who's worth it and who isn't. It's just gotten better at calling it something else, while the woman who actually told us what that worth costs gets quietly moved off the list.
The girls of the 90s who wanted those wings are in our thirties now, and the question we're left with isn't innocent anymore: did anything actually change, or did we just learn to applaud the same trick under a nicer name?


Comments
Post a Comment